We all agree that Beowulf is definitely a good warrior, with tearing Grendel's arm off and killing Grendel's mother, but does that mean he still possess's good traits for a leader. While he does have a close group of soldier's who are his 'posses' per-say, but are they inspired to follow him because of fear or respect. Or the desire to please a man who inspires them to achieve their greatness? Beowulf, he never really gives a chance for his warriors to prove themselves. He lets one of his men get eaten before he attacks Grendel, then he goes down solo to get Grendel's Mom. I believe that he may be hogging the glory for himself but in reality he may be trying to get the job done without extra lose of life.
Over all Beowulf fits the ideal's of an epic hero, he single handedly kills two of the greatest menaces of his time. He graciously accepts the gifts but still remains humble, that shows a good sign of a leader, a person who can take suggestions but not be controlled by how others view him. He is the embodiment of what we idolizes as a hero and leader, but do these equate to being a good king? We may never know.
I agree with your assessment that he is trying to hog all the glory for himself. I personally think hes selfish, as well. Nice analysis and opinion.
ReplyDeleteI've read Beowulf (casually) but have not seen the movie. I think part of what I like about Beowulf is its antiquity. It's pretty cool that we can read something written by someone over a thousand years ago.
ReplyDeleteWhen Beuowulf doesn't want others prove themselves means that he is a bit arrogant and believes that only he can save defeat evil . Definitely characteristics of a leader. But, could those aspects grow into traits of a king over a long period of time? Maybe!
ReplyDeleteMs. Keitges, I'm not following your statement. If one can defeat evil, said person has characteristics of a leader which in term can grow into that of a "great leader"? hmmmmm interesting.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete